Most likely the PO pulled the distributor out of the distributor housing and put it back in the wrong orientation. Even though the rotor is pointing to #1, this engine is probably not at TDC.
At TDC the rotor is pointing at cylinder #1. When the distributor is pulled out - the distributor must be reinserted and still pointing at cylinder #1. In other words, the gear at the bottom of the distributor must engage the gears end of the camshaft in the relationship as before.
This is how I fixed my Sammy. Mark the clock position of the rotor, pull up on the distributor and reinsert with the rotor pointing at a new position (either clockwise or counter clockwise). You will feel the gears slip in on the next notch.
Then check the timing. If that doesn't work, try going the other way. HTH.
Also, check the o'ring while you have it out.