My dad has gone through 5 drivers side regulators in his Sidekick. He's tried factory replacements, salvage yard parts, and a couple off e-bay and they all end up with the same problem. The cable guides on the plastic spool break and the cable gets all tangled up. What we finally did the last time was buy an electric regulator and managed to modify the door to get it to work. Just a hint though... I was having a lot of problems getting the electric regulator to work until I realized that the glass was binding in exactly the same place it would bind with the manual regulator. Turns out the track guides were bone dry. A few squirts of silicone lubricant to the robber and the electric reg works like a charm.