Okay, but what happens when that aluminum third member takes a nasty shot from a boulder on the trail? I saw Lewis "BillyBob" Scherer shatter a steel third while high-centered on a Badlands trail. I think we can agree that a steel third would be tougher than an aluminum one.
OK, I'll give you that one, but you didn't
start the thread with impact as part of the
strength issue. I would think if you hit a
3rd hard enough to shatter it, even a skid
plate would be hard pressed to hold up to
that kind of impact.
In some cases aluminum can take a hit and
live where a cast iron would break, I'm not
saying this is one of those cases, but cast
iron is more brittle, and therefore more prone
to shattering than aluminum, depending on
the alloy and so forth.
As far as power, my front aluminum 3rd has
held up to the turbo, 5.83 gears and 33-13.5
Super Swampers, tho I'm not locked in front,
I can't complaine, some guys replace the fronts
on a monthly basis
Wild