When I bought my sammy it had the same problem. I thought I would change the crank. I had another idea, I filled the key way slot with J B weld and set the key into it. I let it set up for awhile and then slid on the vibration dampner. I thought it would hold until I got back to it. That was about 20,000 miles ago and still going strong. I figured what do I have to loose. If it didnt work I was going to have to change the crank anyway.
For what it's worth.
Dman