You mention it's "got a doubler" ..
By that do you mean it has dual tcases? (e.g. one from the donor and then the sami case).
If so, are you sure the sami tcase is stock? (might want to verify)
If you go down to 31's then the 4.56 diff gears are going to be WAY too low.
Also, 4k RPM's is perfectly acceptable.
Sounds like you got a good rig. Have fun with it.
A two speed doubler, attached to the transmission and hard connected to the transfer case. It's a Geo Tracker engine/tranny so I'm not 100% on "what" doubler it is, or who makes it (I'm working on that with the original owner). But it's a high/low stick in the cab, and works amazing for bringing the sammi to a crawl.
I'm perplexed at his account that the t-case is stock, but I'm working on asking him that too.
... I know the problem with 31s, and 4:56s.... So, the thought was to go back and try stock gearing (as I have two stock axles to pillage from) but retain the 33s and see what happens with the doubler and T-Case ... leaving it AS-IS. Being it's all a mystery at this point, it's a bunch of guess work. Either way, the 33s are growing on me daily... it's just a bit scary to drive at speed, and knowing even a 32" tire might help makes me like the idea (for the wife).
Keeping a 32" tire, and figuring out the gearing... so it can run up to 60 without trouble, is my goal (at this point).
Thanks for the info on the RPMs... it's tough when I'm so used to my diesel truck and it's low RPMs. Once I replace the starter (in about an hour), I'll take it for another drive and see how it's all calculated (rpm, speed and tire size).
Since you have a 3 speed auto in it, it won't have an overdrive. So by dropping down to 31s, the engine will run even higher RPM than what it does now at 60MPH.
If you have the tracker/sidekick transfer case and samurai transfer case combo, then high range ratio is not affected by the double tcase setup (it is just like you are running a samurai tcase by itself, since the trackick tcase has a 1:1 high range ratio).
If you are sure it has 4.56 axle gears, then you could change to 4.30s and it would lower the RPM at 60MPH.
I don't know if you are familar with samurais and 4 cylinder engines in general. But they will run higher RPMs than what an 8 cylinder or even 6 cylinder will. They kinda have to, to be able to maintain speed.
A constant 3500-4000RPM on the road is acceptable for a 1.6.
...see above. But ya, I know how gear ratios and tire size effect RPM. Of course I wouldn't put 31s on and not re-gear.

Something that will solve a lot of this... is at minimum, a picture of the doubler and t-case setup!! I'm on it... give me a minute.