I was running the same setup as you - 5.12 gears (hybrid rear) and stock t-case and 31" tires on my '87 Sami and it SUCKED off road and wasn't great on road, due to gearing. Lower t-case gears would have made it worse on road (higher rpm's) but will help a little bit off road.
I played with the gearing calculators and I did alot of looking around (to do it once and be done) and ended up going with Trail Tough 6.4 t-case gears and swapping to 4.30 R&P gears. The 6.4 gears offer a 181% low range reduction and only a 17% high range reduction. I wanted some really low crawling gears but still be able to drive on the freeway.
This setup also has my speedo back to being accurate again.
I would like to go to a 33" tire once the 31" tires wear out and this will drop 250 rpm's off at freeway speed but I will lose my accurate speedo again.
The setup you have now is good for :
65mph at 4069 rpm
crawl = 42:1
The 5.12 gears with 4:1 t-case :
65mph at 4554 rpm
crawl = 78:1
The 6.4 t-case with 4.30 R&P :
65mph at 3996 rpm
crawl = 100:1
http://www.grimmjeeper.com/gears.htmlSo to answer the question "do you guys think that these would be good gears for me to go with on my rig?"
I would say it depends on what your daily driving involves such as what speed you need to drive to not be a rolling road block.
For me I wanted to be able to run the freeway to work when needed and any t-case gears with the 5.12 R&P gears would have kept me from safely doing it.