I believe that each vehicle will have a slight advantage over the other in something. But - I'm talking about "overall" what's a better daily driver / weekend warrior.
Okay - remember the idea is that I don't want to do more work, or spend more money than I have to. For tow three big reasons:
1) Cost
2) I live in an appartment. I can "borrow" a garage from time to time, but it's hard. Would rather keep the modding to a minimum. And - mods usually = more tools = more $$$.
3) At least 1/2 the time a mod becomes much harder than anticipated. I'm a big "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" kinda guy.
In other words, I'm trying to AVOID swapping motors or axles in either vehicle.
Mods Either vehicle will get:
Engine goodies (header / larger exhaust)
Lift / Bigger tires
LOTS of underbelly armour
Lockright or Spooled rear, Welded diff in front
From what I can tell it's not easier, or cheaper to lift a Tracker. Most 3"+ lifts in a Samurai are going to cost about $1000 (or more) and require at least a couple days to install. Every time someone has said "No, you can do it cheaper" they're either making their own parts, or not buying parts they SHOULD get (larger shocks, bumpstops, new bushings etc). There are 3"+ lifts for trackicks available for the same price. Since I'll be running full armour + lockers, I won't need more than 3" of lift. If I do - I'll cut fenders to keep my low center of gravity - which is more important to me than lift or flex.
So, I'm looking at it like this - Samurai's and Trackicks can both be had for $1000 - $1500 for clean base vehicles (solid motors, no rust, clean inside and out). Both will require lifts that are around $1000 (quality stuff, no cutting corners). The Trackick already comes with a 1.6L and Power Steering.
I really think I can make a DD Trackick for at least $1000 cheaper (and WAY less effort) than a Sami... since... I won't need to swap power plants (I don't care WHAT kind of gearing I have - a lifted Sami is no good as a DD on the freeway around these hills).
Anyway - I guess what I should be asking is - what kind of rig do you have, how much did it cost you, and how happy are you with it? For those of you with Trackicks (like Quaddawg) have you ever had any problems wheeling it?