That would not be a fair comparison since the only factory shocks I've driven have been worn out. I can compare them to the gasmatics that were custom fit direct replacements for the tracker, though. The longer crown vic ones felt about the same to me, possibly SLIGHTLY softer, but not really enough to say for sure. I know they allow the rear end to flex nicely offroad and the ride is still firm enough not to wander around at all on the road.