Which oil filter is correct one for Samurai?

The blue one was on the engine but acc. to all info I found on the net that one is actually for Swift, Baleno etc.

Silver one is what I got at local store as replacement part and according to the catalog's this one is correct however it just doesn't seem to fit right. Looks like the rubber seal is partially blocking oil passages.

Silver one is part no. 16510-83000 and the blue one 16510-60B11.

Which one should I use?

Thanks for any info.