I would go neon green. That way maybe they wouldn't notice the body color.

Its sad but here in IL (just like in Iowa) about the only ones that survive the rust belt are the barbie kicks. I guess the women that bought them must garage them. However, most I've seen all have hard tops and are well maintained. Hey, I just installed pink tracker seats in my black tracker cause they were in perfect shape and came out of a white tracker (pink underneath) that I parted and junked.
Nice tires. What did those run? Flat black I like on my axles, leafs, frame, but a little shine for the wheels looks good. Amazingly enough I like the look of my black tracker with my stock gloss white sammy rims with Cooper ST 235s. The white kinda pops. I just put new 205s on my stock tracker rims with the hammered silver stock color and I like that too. With that body color though I prefer the look of the stock hammered silver like the rear rim in your pic. Seems to show off the tire a little better.