I don't have any off road experience with them yet, but while tire shopping/comparing the Goodyears appear to be heavier. With that said, I ordered 5 33X10.5X15 BFG Mudders. The saleman tried to sell me the Goodyears, however they did not have a 10.5 or smaller width in 33s. My opinion from the research I did was that the BFGs would be better on the Tracker because of the lighter weight and reduced width available. Of course that was considering only 33s. Given a different size, I possibly would have purchased the Goodyears.