I have had both sets on my rig (until I sold it today), but I would say mud=tsl.....everything else the baja claw is far superior (imo), as far as the tire wear, my claws, which were radials , lasted longer than my tsl's......I'm not too sure about the twice as long...... as far as price, i picked up my claws at the 4 wheel jamboree this year....31 X 10.5 X 15 $100.00 a piece and they threw in a tshirt and hat.... and by the way, i am in the mix of picking up a sweet samurai.....it was time for a change